T�tulo: Manual on the Character and Fitness Process for Application to the Michigan State Bar: Law and Practice
Editor: Authorhouse
Fecha de publicaci�n: 2014
Idioma: Ingl�s
ISBN 10: 1496934105
ISBN 13: 9781496934109
Encuadernaci�n: Paperback / softback
Estado: New
Peso: 210 gramos

Acerca de

Sinopsis

This manual is designed to assist the graduating law student to successfully apply to the State Bar of Michigan. It covers the application process, the affidavit of personal history, and the process and procedure should your application require more formal procedures. This manual is also designed to guide applicants and practitioners to prepare and present their cases succinctly and efficiently.

Fragmento. � Reproducci�n autorizada. Todos los derechos reservados.

Manual on the Character and Fitness Process for Application to the Michigan State Bar

Law and Practice

By Timothy A. Dinan

AuthorHouse LLC

Disclaimer and Preface, vii, 
Acknowledgments, ix, 
Chapter One - Defining Character and Fitness, 1, 
Chapter Two - The SBM APPLICATION PROCESS, 13, 
Chapter Three - The District Committee And The District Committee Meeting, 20, 
Chapter Four - The Standing Committee And Standing Committee Hearing, 28, 
Chapter Five - Hearings Before The Board Of Law Examiners, 38, 
Chapter Six - Final Thoughts, 43, 
APPENDICES, 
APPENDIX A – SBM SCCF Rules, 47, 
APPENDIX B – BLE Rules, 55, 
APPENDIX C – Research Resources, 94, 
APPENDIX D – Examples of Letters of Support Submitted to District Committees, 96, 
APPENDIX E – Questions for Attorney/Witnesses at Standing Committee, 100, 
APPENDIX F – Questions for Treating Professionals at Standing Committee Hearings, 103, 
APPENDIX G – Questions for Lay Persons at Standing Committee Hearings, 105, 
APPENDIX H – Role of Psychotherapy in the Character & Fitness Process By Mary Petersen, LMSW, ACSW, 107,

CHAPTER 1

Defining Character and Fitness

INTRODUCTION

The legal profession in Michigan has a unique system of admitting and regulating its members. Unlike many occupations, attorneys are self-regulating and, to a certain extent, self-selective. A number of histories have examined how American attorneys in training (clerks), following the English tradition, would intern with other attorneys to study the law with mentors. When clerks were deemed ready, they were presented to the local bench and bar who decided whether the apprentice had met the standard for practice, thus "passing the bar," the physical barrier dividing the front of the court from the rear. It was both literal and figurative.

The modern system has taken the licensure of attorneys from these local bars to statewide uniform administration of applications, uniform vetting of credentials and due process. All states have regulations regarding attorney admissions though there are as many systems and standards as there are states and territories.

Though similar to some professions, the legal profession nonetheless has unique characteristics that set it apart from many other professions. Like all jurisdictions, the State Bar of Michigan follows a traditional review of the applicant's credentials; however, Michigan also has requirements that set it apart.

LEGAL BASIS

There are a number of sources that provide standards for admission to practice in Michigan. These include guides published by the State Bar of Michigan (SBM), classes and seminars held in Michigan law schools and numerous on-line sources for admissions data. However, the best place to start is to examine Michigan Compiled Laws. Statutorily, MCL 600.934 sets forth the standard for applicants to meet regarding fitness and good moral character. It states:

600.934 Qualifications for admission to bar; "good moral character" defined; election to use multi-state bar examination scaled score; disclosure of score.

Sec. 934.

(1) A person is qualified for admission to the bar of this state who proves to the satisfaction of the board of law examiners that he or she is a person of good moral character, is 18 years of age or older, has the required general education, learning in the law, and fitness and ability to enable him or her to practice law in the courts of record of this state, and that he or she intends in good faith to practice or teach law in this state. Additional requirements concerning the qualifications for admission are contained in subsequent sections of this chapter. As used in this subsection, "good moral character" means good moral character as defined and determined under 1974 PA 381, MCL 338.41 to 338.47.

(2) A person may elect to use the multi-state bar examination scaled score that the person achieved on a multi-state bar examination administered in another state or territory when applying for admission to the bar of this state, but only if all of the following occur:

(a) The score that the person elects to use was achieved on a multi-state examination administered within the 3 years immediately preceding the multi-state bar examination in this state for which the person would otherwise sit.

(b) The person achieved a passing grade on the bar examination of which the multi-state examination the score of which the person elects to use was a part.

(c) The multi-state examination the score of which the person elects to use was administered in a state or territory that accords the reciprocal right to elect to use the score achieved on the multi-state examination administered in this state to Michigan residents seeking admission to the bar of that state or territory.

(d) The person earns a grade on the essay portion of the bar examination that when combined with the transferred multi-state scaled score constitutes a passing grade for that bar examination.

(e) The person otherwise meets all requirements for admission to the bar of this state.

(3) The state board of law examiners shall disclose to a person electing under subsection (2) to transfer the multi-state bar examination scaled score achieved on an examination administered in another state or territory the score the person achieved as soon as that score is received by the board regardless of whether the person could have obtained that score in the jurisdiction in which the examination was administered. This subsection does not require disclosure by the board of the score achieved on a multi-state bar examination administered in another state or territory until the scores achieved on that examination administered in Michigan are released.

History: 1961, Act 236, Eff. Jan. 1, 1963;-- Am. 1972, Act 87, Imd. Eff. Mar. 20, 1972;-- Am. 1978, Act 289, Eff. July 10, 1978;-- Am. 1980, Act 271, Imd. Eff. Oct. 6, 1980;-- Am. 2000, Act 112, Imd. Eff. May 24, 2000;-- Am. 2004, Act 558, Imd. Eff. Jan. 3, 2005 Constitutionality: Requirement of United States citizenship as a necessary prerequisite for the admission to the practice of law constitutes denial of equal protection of the law under Const 1963, art I, � 2, and US Const, am XIV, � 1. In re Houlahan, 389 Mich 665; 209 NW2d 250 (1973), decided prior to the 1978 amendment.

MCL 600.934(1) uses precise language to set forth its requirements. To practice law in Michigan, you must demonstrate to the satisfaction of the Board of Law Examiners that the applicant:

1. Is 18 years or older;

2. Has the required general education, learning in the law;

3. Has the fitness and ability to enable him or her to practice law in the courts of record in Michigan;

4. Intends in good faith to practice or teach law in Michigan; and

5. Possess 'good moral character'

These are not the only requirements. The Michigan Supreme Court, through the Board of Law Examiners, sets forth more specific requirements in terms of law school requirements, passing scores on the MPRE (Multistate Professional Responsibility Examination) and, of course, the Michigan Bar Examination.

GOOD MORAL CHARACTER

Section (1) references MCL 338.41 through 338.47 as to what constitutes "good moral character." MCL 338.41 states:

338.41 "Good moral character" and "principal department" defined.

Sec. 1.

(1) The phrase "good moral character", or words of similar import, when used as a requirement for an occupational or professional license or when used as a requirement to establish or operate an organization or facility regulated by this state in the Michigan Compiled Laws or administrative rules promulgated under those laws shall be construed to mean the propensity on the part of the person to serve the public in the licensed area in a fair, honest, and open manner. [Emphasis added.]

(2) As used in this act, "principal department" means the department which has jurisdiction over the board or agency issuing the license.

History: 1974, Act 381, Eff. Apr. 1, 1975;-- Am. 1978, Act 294, Imd. Eff July 10, 1978 Compiler's Notes: For transfer of powers and duties of adult foster care licensing from the department of social services to the director of the department of commerce, see E.R.O. No. 1996-1, compiled at MCL 330.3101 of the Michigan Compiled Laws. For transfer of powers and duties of the bureau of family services from the department of consumer and industry services to the family independence agency by Type II transfer, see E.R.O. No. 2003-1, compiled at MCL 445.2011. (Id.)

For purposes of an application to practice law, the phrase, "... a propensity on the part of the person to serve the public in the licensed area in a fair, honest, and open manner." ... defines the most important characteristics of what attorneys need to possess. While these terms may not have the same import for other professions, attorneys are officers of the court, agents of their clients as well as servants of their clients (albeit a paid servant). This implies fiduciary duties on a licensed attorney in regard to conduct not only with clients, but with the courts and the general public as well as in accordance with the Michigan Rules of Professional Conduct (MRPC) 1.8. Thus, the SBM looks for past conduct that, if still present, would hinder an applicant's ability to practice within these standards.

Such a broad and open definition allows for varying interpretations by applicants as well as SBM's Standing Committee and District Committee members. Phrases such as "protect the public" and "entrust to the public" are often used in committee hearings and seen in written opinions. These references relate back to that fundamental definition.

PRIOR CRIMINAL HISTORY

The second statute referenced in MCL 600.943 is MCL 338.42. This statute discusses the effect of a criminal conviction on an applicant who wishes to practice law. It holds:

338.42 Judgment of guilt in criminal prosecution or judgment in civil action as evidence in determining good moral character; notice; rebuttal.

Sec. 2.

A judgment of guilt in a criminal prosecution or a judgment in a civil action shall not be used, in and of itself, by a licensing board or agency as proof of a person's lack of good moral character. It may be used as evidence in the determination, and when so used the person shall be notified and shall be permitted to rebut the evidence by showing that at the current time he or she has the ability to, and is likely to, serve the public in a fair, honest, and open manner, that he or she is rehabilitated, or that the substance of the former offense is not reasonably related to the occupation or profession for which he or she seeks to be licensed. [Emphasis added.]

Manual on the Character and Fitness Process for Application to the Michigan State Bar History: 1974, Act 381, Eff. Apr. 1, 1975;-- Am. 1978, Act 294, Imd. Eff. July 10, 1978 Compiler's Notes: For transfer of powers and duties of the bureau of family services from the department of consumer and industry services to the family independence agency by Type II transfer, see E.R.O. No. 2003-1, compiled at MCL 445.2011. (Ibid.)

Here, the effect of a criminal conviction or judgment in a civil action does not itself prevent one from being licensed. However, it does allow that the conviction to be used as evidence whether the applicant will conduct himself in a fair, honest and open manner. It allows for consideration of whether the person is rehabilitated, how the conviction is associated to the crime and whether that association/judgment affects the ability of the applicant to act in a fair, honest and open manner in the legal profession.

In a profession based in the law, it is a reasonable inquiry for SBM to know the facts of an arrest or a conviction. Sometimes, these revelations demonstrate isolated circumstances and anomalies in an otherwise normal history. Applicants often learn from these experiences and can demonstrate their maturation. Each incident is unique and must be considered in light of the applicant's complete history and circumstances. In instances of re-occurring or serial behaviors, the committee will look for a greater degree of effort in rehabilitation. Restitution and compliance with court orders are relevant as is conduct after court supervision is terminated.

The State Bar of Michigan Standing Committee on Character and Fitness Rules of Procedure (herein SBMCCF Rules) recognizes the provisions of this statute (See Appendix D—Rule E.3.).

For example, a homicide conviction may not necessarily be a bar to licensure where a fraud or theft conviction may be depending on the factors cited in the statute as well as those enumerated in the SBMCCF Rules. Each case will be individually considered in order for a panel to recommend whether it believes that the applicant has the requisite character and fitness.

In essence, an applicant must explain him or herself. This statute and the SBMCCF Rules provide a forum and a structure within which to do so. A more thorough explanation of how this is done is found in the SBMCCF Rules.

USE OF CRIMINAL RECORDS TO REVIEW APPLICANTS

MCL 338.43 discusses the use of criminal records in the examination process for an applicant seeking a license. Keep in mind these statutes apply to all professions, not just the legal profession. It states:

338.43 Using, examining, or requesting certain criminal records prohibited; prerequisites for furnishing criminal records; rules.

Sec. 3.

(1) The following criminal records shall not be used, examined, or requested by a licensing board or agency in a determination of good moral character when used as a requirement to establish or operate an organization or facility regulated by this state, or pursuant to occupational or professional licensure:

(a) Records of an arrest not followed by a conviction.

(b) Records of a conviction which has been reversed or vacated, including the arrest records relevant to that conviction.

(c) Records of an arrest or conviction for a misdemeanor or a felony unrelated to the person's likelihood to serve the public in a fair, honest, and open manner.

(d) Records of an arrest or conviction for a misdemeanor for the conviction of which a person may not be incarcerated in a jail or prison.

(2) A criminal record shall not be furnished to a licensing board or agency except by the principal department, and shall be furnished only after the director of the principal department or a person designated by the director has determined that the information to be provided to the board or agency meets the criteria set forth in this section.

(3) The director or a person designated by the director of the principal department shall promulgate rules for each licensing board or agency under that department's jurisdiction which prescribe the offenses or categories of offenses which the department considers indicate a person is not likely to serve the public as a licensee in a fair, honest, and open manner. Each licensing board or agency may make recommendations to the director regarding the rules to be promulgated. The rules shall be consistent with this act and promulgated pursuant to Act No. 306 of the Public Acts of 1969, as amended, being sections 24.201 to 24.315 of the Michigan Compiled Laws. Prior to the promulgation of the rules pertaining to a board or agency, all felonies shall be considered by the board or agency to be relevant to the ability or likelihood the person will serve the public in a fair, honest and open manner.

History: 1974, Act 381, Eff. Apr. 1, 1975;-- Am. 1978, Act 294, Imd. Eff. July 10, 1978 Compiler's Notes: For transfer of powers and duties of the bureau of family services from the department of consumer and industry services to the family independence agency by Type II transfer, see E.R.O. No. 2003-1, compiled at MCL 445.2011. (Ibid.)

Two questions on the Affidavit of Personal History deal with criminal convictions, expunged convictions, arrests and other matters seemingly barred by the above cited statute. Attorneys and applicants, having been trained in the law, are presumed to be knowledgeable of the law and its consequences. Because of the fiduciary role of attorneys, their access to sensitive data, the trust vested in attorneys by their status and license, and their roles as officers of the court, these matters are required to be disclosed to SBM as a routine part of the application. These records may indicate other problems such as substance abuse or mental illness.

There is no cited case law on the issue of an applicant's purposeful non-disclosure of an arrest not leading to a conviction, an expunged arrest, or a conviction that was set aside. However, it is helpful to note that:

As an agent of the Board of Law Examiners, the State Bar of Michigan's Character and Fitness Committee conducts character and fitness investigations of each bar applicant. Thus, the Board of Law Examiners and the Character and Fitness Committee are designated and empowered to discharge the statutorily defined duties of the Michigan Supreme Court. McCready v Michigan State Bar, 881 F Supp 300, 303 (WD Mich, 1995); Scullion v State Bd of Law Examiners, 102 Mich App 711, 715; 302 NW2d 290 (1981).

(Continues...)

Excerpted from Manual on the Character and Fitness Process for Application to the Michigan State Bar by Timothy A. Dinan. Copyright � 2014 Timothy A. Dinan. Excerpted by permission of AuthorHouse LLC.
All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.
Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site.

"Sobre este t�tulo" puede pertenecer a otra edici�n de este libro.

Descripci�n de la librer�a

The Saint Bookstore has a range of over 1 million titles available.

Ver la p�gina web de la librer�a

Informaci�n empresarial del vendedor

SB ONLINE LTD
50 Devonshire Road, Southport, PR9 7BZ, United Kingdom

Condiciones de venta y env�o

Condiciones de venta

Please order through the Abebooks checkout. We only take orders through Abebooks - We don't take direct orders by email or phone.

Refunds or Returns: A full refund of the purchase price will be given if returned within 30 days in undamaged condition.

As a seller on abebooks we adhere to the terms explained at http://www.abebooks.co.uk/docs/HelpCentral/buyerIndex.shtml - if you require further assistance please email us at orders@thesaintbookstore.co.uk

Derecho al desistimiento

Si es un consumidor, puede rescindir el contrato de acuerdo con lo siguiente. Por consumidor se entiende cualquier persona f�sica que act�e con fines ajenos a su actividad comercial, empresarial, oficio o profesi�n.

Informaci�n sobre el derecho de desistimiento

Derecho legal de desistimiento

Tiene derecho a rescindir este contrato en un plazo de 14 d�as sin dar ning�n motivo.

El periodo de desistimiento vencer� a los 14 d�as desde que usted, o un tercero que no sea el transportista e indicado por usted, adquiera la posesi�n f�sica del �ltimo bien o del �ltimo lote o pieza.

Para ejercer el derecho de desistimiento, complete de forma electr�nica y env�e una declaraci�n clara en nuestro sitio web, desde "Mis compras" en "Mi cuenta". Le enviaremos sin demora un acuse de recibo de dicho desistimiento a trav�s de un soporte duradero (por ejemplo, por correo electr�nico).

Para cumplir con el plazo de desistimiento, basta con que env�e su comunicaci�n relativa al ejercicio del derecho de desistimiento antes de que venza el periodo de desistimiento.

Efectos del desistimiento

Si rescinde este contrato, le reembolsaremos todos los pagos que hayamos recibido de usted, incluidos los gastos de env�o (excepto los gastos adicionales que surjan si elige un tipo de env�o que no sea el tipo de env�o est�ndar m�s econ�mico que ofrecemos).

Podemos hacer una deducci�n del reembolso por la p�rdida de valor de cualquier bien suministrado, si la p�rdida es el resultado de una manipulaci�n innecesaria por su parte.

Efectuaremos el reembolso sin demoras indebidas y, a m�s tardar, 14 d�as despu�s de que se nos informe de su decisi�n de rescindir este contrato.

Efectuaremos el reembolso utilizando el mismo medio de pago que utiliz� para la transacci�n inicial, a menos que haya acordado expresamente lo contrario; en cualquier caso, no incurrir� en ning�n cargo como resultado de dicho reembolso.

Podremos retener el reembolso hasta que hayamos recibido los bienes o hasta que nos haya presentado una prueba de que los ha devuelto, lo que ocurra primero.

Deber� devolver los bienes o entregarlos a THE SAINT BOOKSTORE, Southport, United Kingdom, sin demoras indebidas y, en cualquier caso, en un plazo m�ximo de 14 d�as a partir del d�a en que nos comunique su desistimiento del presente contrato. El plazo se cumple si devuelve la mercanc�a antes de que venza el periodo de 14 d�as. Tendr� que asumir los gastos directos de devoluci�n de los bienes. Usted solo es responsable de la disminuci�n del valor de los bienes como resultado de una manipulaci�n distinta a la necesaria para establecer la naturaleza, las caracter�sticas y el funcionamiento de los bienes.

Excepciones al derecho de desistimiento

El derecho de desistimiento no se aplica a lo siguiente:

La entrega de peri�dicos, diarios o revistas, con la excepci�n de los contratos de suscripci�n; y
El suministro de contenido digital que no se proporcione en un soporte tangible (por ejemplo, en un CD o DVD) si, al hacer el pedido, acept� que pod�amos empezar a entregarlo y que no podr�a desistir una vez iniciada la entrega.

Condiciones de env�o

Most orders usually ship within 1-3 business days, but some can take up to 7 days.

Tarifas de env�o de Reino Unido a Estados Unidos de America

Tarifas de env�o de Reino Unido a Estados Unidos de America
Cantidad del pedido	De 7 a 28 d�as h�biles	De 7 a 28 d�as h�biles
Primer art�culo	EUR 15.07	EUR 17.41

Los plazos de entrega los establecen los vendedores y var�an seg�n el transportista y la ubicaci�n. Los pedidos que pasan por la aduana pueden sufrir retrasos y los compradores son responsables de los aranceles o tarifas asociadas. Los vendedores pueden ponerse en contacto con usted en relaci�n con cargos adicionales para cubrir cualquier aumento en los costes de env�o de los art�culos.