International Aid and National Decision : Development Programs in Malawi, Tanzania, and Zambia
Idioma: inglés
Editorial: Princeton University Press, 1976
- Tapa dura
- Usado

Librería: Better World Books, Mishawaka, IN, Estados Unidos de AmericaBetter World Books
Vendedor de IberLibro desde 3 de agosto de 2006
Condición: Usado - Aceptable
EUR 13,63
Cantidad disponible: 1 disponible
Añadir al carritoDescripción del artículo del vendedor
Former library copy. Pages intact with minimal writing/highlighting. The binding may be loose and creased. Dust jackets/supplements are not included. Includes library markings. Stock photo provided. Product includes identifying sticker. Better World Books: Buy Books. Do Good.
N° de ref. del artículo 5647982-6
- Título
- International Aid and National Decision : Development Programs in Malawi, Tanzania, and Zambia
- Autor
- Gordenker, Leon
- Editorial
- Princeton University Press
- Año de publicación
- 1976
- Estado
- Good
- Encuadernación
- Encuadernación de tapa dura
- Idioma
- inglés
- ISBN 10
- 0691056625
- ISBN 13
- 9780691056623
- Peso del artículo
- 1,191 libras
- Dimensiones
- N/A
In more than one hundred developing countries, international organizations continuously offer practical assistance for economic advancement and social change―assistance that in some cases forms a substantial part of national programs. This book examines international aid in three countries-Malawi, Tanzania, and Zambia―in order to ascertain how assisting organizations exert influence on member governments.
Professor Gordenker draws on interviews, information usually inaccessible to observers, and his own direct field observation of programs established by the United Nations' system of organizations in the three countries during the late 1960s, immediately after their independence from British administration. This period witnessed sharp changes in national development policies and the political turmoil produced by the Rhodesian revolt. The author analyzes in detail the creation, bureaucratic consideration, and execution of important projects. His conclusions cast doubt on the existence of a reliable process by which international organizations may influence national governments, and he explains why such doubt is well-founded.
Originally published in 1976.
The Princeton Legacy Library uses the latest print-on-demand technology to again make available previously out-of-print books from the distinguished backlist of Princeton University Press. These editions preserve the original texts of these important books while presenting them in durable paperback and hardcover editions. The goal of the Princeton Legacy Library is to vastly increase access to the rich scholarly heritage found in the thousands of books published by Princeton University Press since its founding in 1905.
“Sinopsis” puede pertenecer a otra edición de este título.
Fragmento. © Reproducción autorizada. Todos los derechos reservados.
International Aid and National Decision
Development Programs in Malawi, Tanzania, and Zambia
By Leon GordenkerPRINCETON UNIVERSITY PRESS
All rights reserved.
Contents
List of Figures and Tables, vii,
List of Abbreviations, ix,
Preface, xi,
Acknowledgments, xix,
1. International Organization and Field Operations, 3,
2. Structural Counterparts, 52,
3. Influence: Projects, 85,
4. Influence: Advice And Crisis, 119,
5. An International Administrative Instrument, 150,
Index, 183,
CHAPTER 1
INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATION AND FIELD OPERATIONS
The constant, even frenetic, operation of several hundred international institutions of diverse models has so seeped into international relations that it is both taken for granted and regarded as an essential element by national governments. Even though few persons anywhere, and these sometimes reluctantly, pay much attention to this ceaseless, beneficially intended activity, it nevertheless concerns the general welfare and relates with special intensity to the poorer parts of the world.
Promotion of the general welfare — the provision of varied services to the people of the world — in one way or another now preoccupies most of the personnel and takes the lion's share of the finances of most of the broad membership intergovernmental organizations. Although this activity has unexpectedly burgeoned, it nevertheless links with older ideas about the functions of international organizations. In fact, the general welfare services derive for the most part from organizations cast in a rather conventional mold, familiar to all concerned with relations among states since the creation of the League of Nations.
Such international institutions represent attempts to bind their members, the states of the world, to conduct some of their affairs in regular, specified ways. These legally binding commitments shape the expectations that each government has about the behavior of others. Thus a universal standard for judging the behavior and intentions of governments is built up. Constructing standards requires implicit or explicit specification of desirable behavior and interpretations of rules so that governments can guide themselves. The institutions embody and develop processes intended to generate the consent of governments to new or improved policies which will be generally executed. Some of these policies are intended to promote the general welfare and belong to a yet broader, perpetual pressure toward international cooperation. International institutions radiate a general hope, too often forlorn but never abandoned for the long term, of helping to organize the mutual affairs of governments so as to prevent war, adjust conflict, and approach international governing.
This conventional perspective on international organization does not exclude field operations, which are a part of this study, but neither does it necessarily include them. It could be argued that attention to the general welfare, including economic development and social change, creates conditions necessary for organizing cooperative, problem-solving behavior among governments. If field operations are necessary to the promotion of the general welfare, then they are a positive step toward effective international cooperation.
Another perspective is offered by the Functionalist approach to international organization, which emphasizes practical, down-to-earth cooperation. Symbolic commitment to standards has little place in this view, but field operations fit it perfectly. In a sense, the development of field operations by international organizations bridges the differences that have developed among those who think of relations among governments as having a primarily negotiating and bargaining character and those who would abandon such approaches in favor of concrete, directly perceptible benefits.
Both of these perspectives have a global, supragovernmental tone or even bias. Another perspective more closely approaches that of the national capitals. It shows the complex of international organizations and their hedgerows of intertwining recommendations and programs in a different light. The goals of general welfare and orderly relationships remain the same. But the deliberative organs offer the national governments a vast series of opportunities to attempt to manipulate the international structures for their own benefit, however that is interpreted. Yet from this perspective, membership in international organizations has its costs; pressures on a government grow out of such participation and issues are raised, sometimes on the symbolic level, sometimes very practically, to which a government must respond.
Manipulative efforts directed outward by national governments into international bodies are extremely well-documented. Even quite casual readers of daily newspapers can learn about, for example, Egypt's attempt to use the United Nations to secure withdrawal of Israel from captured territories. Furthermore, some manipulation has an almost comforting parliamentary tone, whatever the outcome, for the unmistakable votes of majorities and minorities are registered. The influence exercised by the United States in wide-membership international bodies during the first decade after the Second World War is one illustration of this manipulation. Another can be found in the ability of the Afro-Asian nations to move the General Assembly to ever stronger resolutions to counter the policy of apartheid in South Africa. Again, the UN Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) and the UN Industrial Development Organization (UNIDO) were created primarily to serve the interests of poor countries.
If manipulative attempts, especially at the symbolic level, can be treated as easily recognizable, the reaction of governments to efforts of international organizations to set behavioral patterns through recommendations, urgings, demands, and rewards is far less well understood. Because much of this reactive process necessarily takes place within and around government bureaucracies, it easily becomes and remains obscure. Moreover, it necessarily differs from government to government, depending upon organizational forms and practices, political leaders and their views, and a host of other particular factors. Yet an obvious purpose for the existence of international organizations, whatever the perspective from which they are viewed, is precisely to induce reactions from member governments. Reactions of governments which result from stimulation by the activity of international organizations may be seen as the exercise of influence by those organizations.
This study relates to the generalized flow of influence from international institutions to and from member governments, but it can cover only part of the entire range of such influence. It deals with a subject matter typical of world institutions which reflect in varied proportions all of the perspectives discussed here. These are institutions which can solemnly declare a Second Development Decade after a first one scarcely triumphed in reaching for its goals. These are also institutions which can create a far-reaching administrative network and finance budgets of hundreds of millions of dollars for assistance to national economic development programs. The study centers on the manner in which international organizations work with member governments in efforts to improve the general welfare. In particular, it deals with those specialized programs that have a distinctly novel character in the development of international institutions; these are programs that depend on field operations that reach directly into member countries. Such operations have become characteristic of international institutions which are directed by their members to attempt to provide services for economic development and social change.
The study of influence in any social framework has long been the subject of criticism which monotonously points out the vagueness of the concept, the difficulties in making it operational for research, and the problems in measuring it. It is admittedly difficult to specify when influence, in the sense of inducing a reaction that otherwise might not have taken place, has been exercised. But this is a difficulty that applies frequently to inquiry into any kind of social phenomena: they are complex, frequently obscure, and often involve activity directed to different ends by the engaged parties. Yet it is obvious that international institutions are intended to have relations that cause behavioral reactions in governments. It is just as obvious that the causal impetus may range in intensity from the mildest sort of implied suggestion through various kinds of rewards to direct, forceful coercion. In matters of the general welfare, the causal impetus involves perceived self-interest on the part of governments (including their engaged component parts, e.g., specialized bureaucracies) and rewards for engaging in specific activities which supposedly accord with that self-interest. In this sense, the aim of international institutions is to influence governmental behavior. Evidence of such influence may be found in the manner in which governments and their personnel react to recommendations and policies emanating from international institutions and to possibilities for achieving direct benefits in programmatic form. Such reactions are commonplace in governmental circles. Furthermore, it is conceivable that some programs offered or actually operated by international institutions cause governments to react by attempting to influence the nature of the programs themselves. They may attempt to manipulate the international institutions, i.e., to influence them. It is with such varieties of influence, in concrete instances, that this study is concerned.
The Inquiry
From highly tentative overtures a quarter of a century ago to more intense activity to promote the general welfare, the international community appears to have defined a largely new mode of cooperation — field operations mounted by international institutions of global scope. Because of its novelty, its growth, its potential, and its limitations, it is worth asking how this mode works. This study will attempt to provide some description of recent operations in a framework restricted enough so that considerable and perhaps vivid detail can be presented.
Second, the inquiry will seek to determine what, if any, explicit ideas guide contemporary activities in the field. Much of the output of the deliberative organs of international organizations consists of urging member governments to follow one course in preference to another: thus, the United Nations urges member governments not to lose sight of the social consequences of economic change; and governments are urged to remain aware of social effects in preference to treating them with indifference. It might be assumed that personnel furnished by the UN system for field work would be guided by such recommendations and that governments would be enlightened by them. But is there evidence of such doctrinal penetration? What conclusions can be drawn from such evidence?
Third, if field administrative structures are created in member countries by the international organizations to which they belong, it could be expected that their operations would give a distinct tone to the policies of the recipient governments. This hypothesis will be tested as far as possible.
Fourth, if international organizations create administrative apparatus that works in different countries, it could be expected that the mode of operation is similar in each location. This hypothesis will be tested in three countries. An attempt will be made to account for any differences that occur.
Finally, some focal points of activity provide better possibilities for observation than would be found in simply broad description. One of these points is the office of Resident Representative. It is hypothesized that the Resident Representative develops a crucial relationship with the host government and that he sets a distinctive mode of operation which shapes the pattern of influence.
Extension of Influential Relationships
An end product of the sprawling network of international organizations and a principal object of their programs comprises services for governments on their own territories. This obviously contrasts with the earlier pattern of centralized services, such as statistical collations, which governments were free to use as general resources. Among the services now provided are technical advice, training, high level administrative personnel, and loans. One way or another, closely or distantly, these services are intended to relate to economic development and concomitant social change deliberately promoted by recipient governments.
Because economic development is the very stuff of politics — the kernel of crucial decisions — in many less developed countries (LDCs) the work of international organizations necessarily and increasingly touches on controversial and delicate national issues. To make recommendations about the organization of an educational system, to arm a minister of transport with arguments for extending a road network that competes for capital funds with a weapons-seeking defense ministry, to urge population control on a people who for the first time in the memory of the oldest man enjoy reasonably good health is to become involved in politics. True, the involvement is not partisan in the sense of taking part in an election, or as definite as would be the formal and real power to make final, authoritative, general decisions. Furthermore, formally and, so far, ultimately, the recipient government retains all powers of final decision on joint ventures and has complete freedom to accept or reject advice or loans.
Yet it is a fact — one that is characteristic of international institutions one third of a century after the formation of the United Nations — that in a large number of countries, governmental decisions for the first time in history take into account advice proffered by personnel formally representing neither private interests nor the government for whose benefit they work. These officials, employed by international organizations, operate within or (more frequently) parallel to national civil services and have access to the full range of technical working papers pertaining to the issues in their purview. Some of them take up only highly defined problems, such as the rate of flow of water in a river at various seasons over a number of years, and produce characteristically specialized reports. But some of the advisers have mandates broad enough to match such titles as "Economic Adviser to the Government" and have direct and frequent access to responsible ministers at the top of government.
Furthermore, governments increasingly seek advisers, sometimes at the suggestion of international organization representatives, for the purpose of preparing a request for assistance on a larger scale or for a loan from one of the international financial organizations. It is ever more common to find a team of experts, sent by the UN Development Program (UNDP) or a regional UN economic commission, hard at work on plans for a training institute or a pilot plant. The counsel offered by such advisers, it might be assumed, necessarily strives to meet the standards believed appropriate for the organization from which future aid is to be sought. In this sense, a government receives outside advice in order to build into its own information and decision-making structures the standards of outside organizations. Such incorporation of international standards may take place in a scarcely conscious manner or may be quite deliberate and explicit. This line of reasoning leads to the proposition that, by seeking and receiving aid from international organizations, governments of LDCs introduce substantive advice and advisory personnel which influence their own domestic political processes. In fact, this manifestation of international organization penetrates deeper into the domestic process than was expected or earlier experienced.
A corollary of this proposition holds that the conceptions of sovereignty enshrined in the constitutional instruments of international organizations — and perhaps most strikingly in the case of the United Nations — do not precisely conform to the reality of operational programs. The time-honored principle that each government absolutely controls its policies with regard to other governments permeates these constitutional instruments, and probably also the conceptions of international cooperation held by many diplomatic personnel. In the formal, legal sense, the members of international organizations are states equal to one another in legal capacity. All have reserved domestic jurisdictions which, if the concept has any meaning, are capable of definition.
(Continues...)
Excerpted from International Aid and National Decision by Leon Gordenker. Copyright © 1976 Princeton University Press. Excerpted by permission of PRINCETON UNIVERSITY PRESS.
All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.
Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site.
“Acerca de” puede pertenecer a otra edición de este título.
Better World Books
Mishawaka, IN, Estados Unidos de America
Vendedor de IberLibro desde 3 de agosto de 2006
Tarifas de envío en Estados Unidos de America
| Artículo | De 4 a 8 días hábiles | De 3 a 5 días hábiles |
|---|---|---|
| Primer artículo | EUR 0,00 | EUR 13,61 |
Métodos de pago
Descripción de la tienda
Better World Books (https://www.BetterWorldBooks.com) is a for-profit, socially conscious business and a global online bookseller that collects and sells new and used books online, matching each purchase with a book donation. Each sale generates funds for literacy and education initiatives in the U.S., the UK, and around the world. Since its launch in 2003, Better World Books has raised $33 million for libraries and literacy, donated over 32 million books, and reused or recycled more than 397 million books.…
Información empresarial del vendedor
Better World Books Marketplace, Inc.
55740 Currant Road
Mishawaka, IN Estados Unidos de America 46545
Condiciones de venta
Better World Books (BWB) values your satisfaction and offers you returns within thirty (30) days after the estimated delivery date on most items. All returned items must be in the original condition; used items should include the SKU sticker located on the spine or back of the product.
If you have an incomplete, incorrect, or damaged shipment, please contact our Customer Care team via Abebooks contact seller options before proceeding with the return.Please keep in mind that because we deal mostly in used books, any extra components, such as CDs, DVDs, figurines, or access codes are not included.
Derecho al desistimiento
Si es un consumidor, puede rescindir el contrato de acuerdo con lo siguiente. Por consumidor se entiende cualquier persona física que actúe con fines ajenos a su actividad comercial, empresarial, oficio o profesión.
Información sobre el derecho de desistimiento
Derecho legal de desistimiento
Tiene derecho a rescindir este contrato en un plazo de 14 días sin dar ningún motivo.
El periodo de desistimiento vencerá a los 14 días desde que usted, o un tercero que no sea el transportista e indicado por usted, adquiera la posesión física del último bien o del último lote o pieza.
Para ejercer el derecho de desistimiento, complete de forma electrónica y envíe una declaración clara en nuestro sitio web, desde "Mis compras" en "Mi cuenta". Le enviaremos sin demora un acuse de recibo de dicho desistimiento a través de un soporte duradero (por ejemplo, por correo electrónico).
Para cumplir con el plazo de desistimiento, basta con que envíe su comunicación relativa al ejercicio del derecho de desistimiento antes de que venza el periodo de desistimiento.
Efectos del desistimiento
Si rescinde este contrato, le reembolsaremos todos los pagos que hayamos recibido de usted, incluidos los gastos de envío (excepto los gastos adicionales que surjan si elige un tipo de envío que no sea el tipo de envío estándar más económico que ofrecemos).
Podemos hacer una deducción del reembolso por la pérdida de valor de cualquier bien suministrado, si la pérdida es el resultado de una manipulación innecesaria por su parte.
Efectuaremos el reembolso sin demoras indebidas y, a más tardar, 14 días después de que se nos informe de su decisión de rescindir este contrato.
Efectuaremos el reembolso utilizando el mismo medio de pago que utilizó para la transacción inicial, a menos que haya acordado expresamente lo contrario; en cualquier caso, no incurrirá en ningún cargo como resultado de dicho reembolso.
Podremos retener el reembolso hasta que hayamos recibido los bienes o hasta que nos haya presentado una prueba de que los ha devuelto, lo que ocurra primero.
Deberá devolver los bienes o entregarlos a Better World Books, Mishawaka, Indiana, U.S.A., sin demoras indebidas y, en cualquier caso, en un plazo máximo de 14 días a partir del día en que nos comunique su desistimiento del presente contrato. El plazo se cumple si devuelve la mercancía antes de que venza el periodo de 14 días. Tendrá que asumir los gastos directos de devolución de los bienes. Usted solo es responsable de la disminución del valor de los bienes como resultado de una manipulación distinta a la necesaria para establecer la naturaleza, las características y el funcionamiento de los bienes.
Excepciones al derecho de desistimiento
El derecho de desistimiento no se aplica a lo siguiente:
- La entrega de periódicos, diarios o revistas, con la excepción de los contratos de suscripción; y
- El suministro de contenido digital que no se proporcione en un soporte tangible (por ejemplo, en un CD o DVD) si, al hacer el pedido, aceptó que podíamos empezar a entregarlo y que no podría desistir una vez iniciada la entrega.
Condiciones de envío
Please allow 1-2 business days for order fulfillment.