The Heretic's Guide to Best Practices: The Reality of Managing Complex Problems in Organisations
Idioma: inglés
Editorial: iUniverse, 2013
- Tapa blanda
- Usado

Librería: Clevedon Community Bookshop Benefit Society, Clevedon, Reino UnidoClevedon Community Bookshop Benefit Society
Vendedor de IberLibro desde 9 de enero de 2013
Condición: Usado - Aceptable
EUR 7,37
Cantidad disponible: 1 disponible
Añadir al carritoDescripción del artículo del vendedor
All of our books without an ISBN number (normally pre-1970 in date) are described individually in detail. Books with an ISBN number (this one included) are all offered for sale in good condition or better: some may be in very good, near fine, or fine condition. If the condition is critical to your decision to purchase, then please contact us and we will let you know our view of its condition. If the book is very heavy, we will may need to contact you before completion of purchase to advise you of extra postage costs.
N° de ref. del artículo 69941
- Título
- The Heretic's Guide to Best Practices: The Reality of Managing Complex Problems in Organisations
- Autor
- Culmsee, Paul; Awati, Kailash
- Editorial
- iUniverse
- Año de publicación
- 2013
- Estado
- Good
- Encuadernación
- Soft cover
- Idioma
- inglés
- ISBN 10
- 1938908406
- ISBN 13
- 9781938908408
“Sinopsis” puede pertenecer a otra edición de este título.
Fragmento. © Reproducción autorizada. Todos los derechos reservados.
The Heretic's Guide to Best Practices
The Reality of Managing Complex Problems in Organisations
By Paul Culmsee, Kailash AwatiiUniverse, Inc.
All rights reserved.
Contents
| Part 1..................................................................... | |
| Introduction: Losing our Marbles........................................... | 3 |
| 1 Platitudes: Empty Words that Make the Most Noise......................... | 13 |
| 2 A Mind Field of Errors................................................... | 37 |
| 3 Myths, Memes and Methodologies........................................... | 64 |
| 4 Managing Innovation: The Demise of Command and Control................... | 84 |
| 5 There Are Problems and There Are "Problems".............................. | 106 |
| 6 In Praise of Dialogue: From Bounded to Communicative Rationality......... | 123 |
| Interlude: From problems to solutions...................................... | 146 |
| Part 2..................................................................... | |
| 7 Visualising Reasoning.................................................... | 153 |
| 8 Argumentation-based Rationale............................................ | 182 |
| 9 Problem Structuring Methods.............................................. | 212 |
| 10 Rationality and Relationships........................................... | 246 |
| 11 From theory to practice................................................. | 284 |
| Part 3..................................................................... | |
| 12 Planners and Precinct 5................................................. | 289 |
| 13 Taming Definitions, Bywords and Platitudes.............................. | 321 |
| 14 The Practice of Dialogue Mapping........................................ | 349 |
| Coda....................................................................... | 371 |
| References................................................................. | 379 |
| Index...................................................................... | 389 |
| About the Authors.......................................................... | 393 |
CHAPTER 1
Platitudes:Empty Words that Make the Most Noise
Market churn has set us adrift.
What we need is a paradigm shift.
Get our ducks in a row,
push the envelope,
to keep us from going o'er the cliff.
The boss says, "Let's touch base.
Make game-plans for the next phase.
We'll have meetings and talks.
Think outside the box,
to ensure we're still in the race."
But the elephant in the room
refuses to sing to our tune,
or dance to our beat,
sing from the same sheet
—even once in a blue moon.
From "A cliché-ridden corporate crisis in five limericks" (Kailash Awati)
We are an elite team ...
What better way to start a book that takes a critical look at all the messedup stuff going on in organisations than with the cult movie "MysteryMen," starring Ben Stiller, Hank Azaria and William H. Macey.
In this movie, the fate of Champion City rests in the hands of sevenself-declared superheroes. The reality is that our intrepid "heroes" are fairlyinept. Among them, we have the perpetually angry "Mr Furious," the forkflinging "Blue Raja," "The Shoveler" and the mysterious "Sphinx." Despitetheir individual failings, which they are oblivious to, they somehow bandtogether to triumph against the evil "Casanova Frankenstein."
The Sphinx character is our favourite. He is a master ofquasi-philosophical, Zen-like utterances that have no meaning whatsoever.Consider the following classic Sphinxisms:
"To learn my teachings, I must first teach you how to learn."
"You must lash out with every limb, like the octopus who playsthe drums."
"He who questions training only trains himself at askingquestions."
At one point, Mr Furious grows tired of these teachings, and thisfollowing dialogue ensues:
MR FURIOUS: Okay, am I the only one who finds these sayings just a little bitformulaic? (Mimicking the sphinx) If you want to push somethingdown, you have to pull it up. If you want to go left, you have togo right. It's ...
SPHINX: Your temper is very quick, my friend. But until you learn tomaster your rage ...
MR FURIOUS: Your rage will become your master? That's what you were goingto say. Right? Right?
SPHINX: ... Not necessarily
This exchange is a classic illustration of a platitude: a meaninglessstatement that is presented as if it were significant and original. The wordis derived from plat, the French word for flat. Platitudes are exceedinglycommon in management and consulting circles. In a paper, Barabba,Pourdenhad and Ackoff (2002) stated that:
"... consultants are of two types: self-promoting gurus andeducators. Gurus that pontificate and promote their proprietaryproblem solving techniques do not educate their clients. Theypromote maxims that define rules of behaviour but do notincrease the competence of managers. They promote theirproprietary solution as a fix for all problems instead of tryingto increase managerial understanding of a particular corporatepuzzle. They provide maxims that are really platitudes andpanaceas without proof of effectiveness ..."
Of course, one person's profundity may be another's platitude;whether or not a particular statement is platitudinous is indeed subjective.Nevertheless, the term is often used in a pejorative sense to describeseemingly profound statements that a particular person views as unoriginalor shallow. In this chapter we'll examine platitudes, some blatant, others alittle more subtle, to see just how insidious they are and what they can tellyou about the culture and maturity of organisations.
Mission and vision statements—too easy
The first and most obvious fertile hunting ground for platitudes that ourfriend, the Sphinx, would be proud of would have to be organisationalmission and vision statements.
"The mission and vision statement maketh the organisation," says theCEO. But does it really? Will those couple of sentences in large font,proudly hanging on the wall behind reception, serve as the rudder used bymanagement to guide the organisation to greatness?
For many reasons we think not, but we are not the first to be cynical.This topic has been done to death elsewhere, so we will simply touch onit here before we get to our main point.
For a start, the phrase "mission statement" is not the latest, nor is itthe first term to be used to describe organisational aims and objectives.Nowadays though, many organisations do not label their aims andobjectives as a mission statement.
So, why does a term like "mission statement" go out of fashion?Typically, this happens when everyone starts using it at every opportunity.
Soon, the term loses its original intent, impact and import. The firstpeople to notice this loss of meaning are those on the receiving end ofthe platitude; employees who have to translate the mission statement intoreality. For these folks, Mission Impossible and Simpsonesque farce cometo mind: "Your mission, should you choose to accept it, is to make thisorganisation Number One in Excellence ..."
Nevertheless, executives are fascinated by platitudinous aphorisms.Legions of management consultants have figured this out. Moreover,getting in on the act is surprisingly simple. All you need to do is watchfor incipient buzzwords and use them before your competitors do. Forexample, to be really cool and up to speed on the latest in high platitudefashion, you need only to appreciate that "mission statement" is like ...so 20th century. Now, if you want to be seen or heard, you need a "Noblepurpose". No one takes mission statements seriously anymore, but a noblepurpose will positively have employees jumping for joy. Remember whereyou heard it first people—right here in this book. No royalty necessary foruse of this term, an acknowledgement will do.
The more popular things get, the more common place they become. Then,regardless of the original noble intentions behind them, they are overusedand ultimately depleted. Like a stock market rally, by the time everyone hascaught on, the smart money has moved on. Eventually, it becomes a ritual,something that has lost its original meaning rather than an action with apurpose. In short, the mission and vision statement is done because it is whatyou are supposed to do. After all, a document with a mission and a visionstatement is so much more ... "professional," right? So, not only will we doit, but we'll hire $5000 a day consultants to help us create one. After all, whobetter than a rank outsider to tell us what we're supposed to be doing?
Yes, this perverse logic is all too common. We'll venture an explanationfor this phenomenon in Chapter 3. For now, let's move on with ourdiscussion of platitudes.
Over the years we have developed finely honed radars for platitudes.One particularly easy way to spot them is via the "excellence test." In thefinal episode of series three of The Simpsons, the TV show, Homer wasrendered infertile due to years of radiation exposure. Fearing a lawsuit,the nuclear power plant created an award called the "OutstandingAchievement in the Field of Excellence" and awarded it to Homer. As faras platitudes go, this award is sheer genius and is the yardstick that we willbe using when rating organisational mission statements. Thus, from thevery beginning, the example below was doomed to fail:
"Our mission is to conduct all of our businesses, both energyand financial related, with four key values in mind: respect,integrity, communication and excellence. All business dealingsmust be conducted in an environment that is open and fair."
You see? As soon as the word excellence is there, we know that thereis trouble. This was allegedly the mission statement of a little companycalled Enron, (yeah ... that Enron!), whose scandalous downfall wasthe largest bankruptcy in American history at the time, taking out theaccounting and audit firm Arthur Andersen with it and being part of thereason for the Sarbanes Oxley regime currently operating in the USA.
Of course, our "excellence" platitude detection test lacks rigour becauseit misses out on an infinite number of platitudes that do not contain theword excellence. A better option is to follow the philosophy of RussellAckoff (1987). Ackoff believed that an organisation's or group's missionstatement must not state the obvious. The reason is simple: A missionstatement that merely restates the obvious does not say anything that istruly aspirational. To quote from Ackoff:
"They (groups and organisations) often formulate necessitiesas objectives: For example, `to achieve sufficient profit.' This islike a person saying his mission is to breathe sufficiently."
One of Ackoff's criteria to judge the quality of a mission statementis to see if the inverse of the statement makes logical sense. If you cannotreasonably disagree with this negative, then the original statement is aplatitude. Here are two examples:
"... our mission and values are to help people and businessesthroughout the world realize their full potential." (Microsoft2011)
So, our inverse here is working to hinder people and businesses torealise their full potential. Hmm, after the Windows Vista experience,some people would consider Microsoft's mission statement more of anoxymoron! The next statement is attributed to General Motors (King,Case and Premo 2010):
"... a multinational corporation engaged in socially responsibleoperations, worldwide. It is dedicated to provide products and servicesof such quality that our customers will receive superior value whileour employees and business partners will share in our success andour stock-holders will receive a sustained superior return on theirinvestment."
So, the inverse of this is a socially irresponsible company that producesoverpriced goods of poor quality and treats employees, partners andshareholders like crap ... Speaking of the fast food industry, here is amission statement attributed to more than one player in that space:
"We will prepare and sell quick service food to fulfil ourguests' needs more accurately, quickly, courteously, and in acleaner environment than our competitors. We will conductall our business affairs ethically, and with the best employeesin the mid-south. We will continue to grow profitably andresponsibly, and provide career advancement opportunities forevery willing member of our organisation."
This is actually the best mission statement so far. The aspirations arevery clear and easily measurable. What about this?
"We are dedicated to ensuring a long-term commitment tostakeholder value from performance and improved returns atall levels."
That one was a trick assessment. We generated it from a website whereyou can generate your very own mission statement. It works like a pokermachine. Just pull the lever and within a few seconds, a random assortmentof small quotes are mashed together to create a mission statement. If youenter your company name into it, you can even print a certificate.
Finally for now, we wonder if you can guess whose organisationalmission this is:
"To produce high-quality, low cost, easy to use products thatincorporate high technology for the individual. We are provingthat high technology does not have to be intimidating fornon-computer experts."
The inverse implies that we produce low quality, high cost and hardto use products. But the second sentence redeems the statement because itis measurable. We like the notion of any mission statement starting with"we are proving" because for the next part of the sentence to make sense,it really has to be measurable. In case you didn't guess it, this is attributedto Apple in 1984. Given their market success with anything with thelowercase letter "i" in front of it, we have to concede that they really haveachieved that particular mission.
Just because you say it, doesn't mean it's true
In a paper entitled "Silenced by a Mission Statement: An Organisation'sCloak of Ambiguity," Gina Rathbun (2007) described her experiences ina company which had a ritual of chanting the company mission statementfrom a laminated card at the start of every monthly staff meeting. As youread Rathbun's quote below, try and keep in mind the characters fromthe "Mystery Men," all dressed up in their costumes, starting their day ofcrime-fighting in a similar manner.
"Before the meeting commenced, we were instructed to "takeout" our cards, which contained the vague metaphoricallanguage ... The mission statement's chant began:
We are an elite team of inter-dependent professionals, who areexperts at creating upscale living environments. We cultivatesituational awareness and act with professionalism and integrity.We are proud. We are a team."
Rathbun noted that the mission statement recited during thesemeetings said nothing of where the organisation was going. A little laterin the paper, she said:
"... Even the platitudes "elite" and "proud" ascribed a banalitythat didn't provide much direction toward describing any realbehaviour. Isn't any company that takes the time to formulateits values collectively, proud? What values exactly was thePresident endorsing?"
The point about the mission statement saying nothing about where theorganisation was headed actually points to the way to get past platitudes. Itmay come as a surprise to readers that trying to define them is not the way.
Definitions and bywords
One thing that we all tend to get suckered into doing at times is classifyingand defining the objects and ideas we work with. Granted, this is oftenunavoidable, especially in the world of academia where definitionsare needed in order to ensure that everyone understands what's beingdiscussed. Once you read a few papers however, you begin to notice apattern. Many papers, particularly in the social sciences, start out with aten page examination of all the past definitions of things that are beingexamined in the paper. This is followed by an equally tedious discussionof why those definitions are inadequate or incomplete, thereby pavingthe way for a new set of definitions. The remainder of the paper will bea detailed justification as to why the new, improved definitions are betterthan their predecessors.
Defining stuff is a time consuming and tiring exercise. Since we livein a world of constant change there will always be new influences whichshape and frame perceptions. Therefore, a definition that an authorlovingly spends so much effort on coming up with is always subject tobeing redefined by the next academic, blogger or marketing person whofollows a similar path. This cycle plays out in a few ways:
• The new definition becomes more verbose. There are a couple ofreasons for this:
* The definition is expanded to incorporate new aspects ofthe topic space. In an organisational setting, this createsconfusion because the definitions of multiple disciplinescan often seemingly contradict each other and thus, careful"wordsmithing" is required to navigate a path through it.
* New qualifications or exceptional situations have to beexcluded. This leads to more new terms being used in thedefinition.
• A broader, fundamental definition is developed. The broaderdefinition encompasses more and so is prone to platitudinousleanings. Further, such definitions also run the risk of beinginterpreted in ways other than the one intended by the author.
• A new word is used or an existing word is used in a new contextto try and convey the new meanings or concepts proposed by theauthor. If the author gets lucky, it catches on. The metamorphosisfrom "mission statement" to "noble purpose" is an example ofthis point.
While it might seem that we are arguing against definitions, be assuredwe aren't. What we wish to point out is that the tendency to "definitionise"has crept into organisational settings where it is wholly inappropriate.Bywords (and their definitions) are fertile ground for a dangerous kind ofplatitude which can doom projects before they even begin.
"How do you measure quality, then?"
A common characteristic of a platitude is that it has no meaning untilit is applied to a particular situation. Words in this category includequality, security, flexibility, innovation, effectiveness and Paul's personalfavourite, governance. These words have plenty written about them and,accordingly, have many definitions. The mistake is to try and lock down adefinition in an attempt to provide context to a situation or problem. Thiscreates a very sneaky and dangerous platitude; one that deludes peopleinto thinking that there is more shared understanding between peoplethan there actually is.
(Continues...)
Excerpted from The Heretic's Guide to Best Practices by Paul Culmsee, Kailash Awati. Copyright © 2013 Paul Culmsee and Kailash Awati. Excerpted by permission of iUniverse, Inc..
All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.
Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site.
“Acerca de” puede pertenecer a otra edición de este título.
Clevedon Community Bookshop Benefit Society
Clevedon, Reino Unido
Vendedor de IberLibro desde 9 de enero de 2013
Tarifas de envío de Reino Unido a Estados Unidos de America
| Artículo | De 7 a 11 días hábiles | De 7 a 11 días hábiles |
|---|---|---|
| Primer artículo | EUR 18,08 | EUR 18,08 |
Métodos de pago
- PayPal
Descripción de la tienda
Clevedon Community Bookshop, co-operatively owned, opened on 31 December 2011 and now has a general stock of approximately 20,000 books. Our Bookshop is in Copse Road in Clevedon and is open every day of the week except Mondays, from 10.30am to 4.30pm. The Bookshop Co-operative comprises nearly 650 members from around the world and was set up to stop the only second-hand bookshop in our town from closing. The benefit of being a member/shareholder is only social: no-one benefits financially. All profits are used to improve the bookshop and its stock, and, through events, to contribute to the literacy and literary profile of our town. If you would like you join the Co-operative and co-own the Bookshop with us, please email us.…
Especialidad
letters and diaries, short stories, poetry, transport, travel, history, local studies - south west england, childrens, art, natural history, biographyInformación empresarial del vendedor
Clevedon Community Bookshop Co-operative
Unit 15, Tweed Road Industrial Estate, Tweed Road
Clevedon, Reino Unido BS21 6RR
Condiciones de venta
Clevedon Community Bookshop Co-operative Ltd is a co-operative registered with
the FCA, registration number 31395R. Its share capital at 21 May 2014 amounted
to £14,850.
We take care to describe our books accurately and in detail, and to pack them so that they arrive with you in the same condition that they leave us. However,
should you not be completely satisfied with your purchase, then you may return
the books(s) to us and, provided you do this within 30 days of receiving the
book(s), then we will fully refund the cost of the book and postage.
Derecho al desistimiento
Si es un consumidor, puede rescindir el contrato de acuerdo con lo siguiente. Por consumidor se entiende cualquier persona física que actúe con fines ajenos a su actividad comercial, empresarial, oficio o profesión.
Información sobre el derecho de desistimiento
Derecho legal de desistimiento
Tiene derecho a rescindir este contrato en un plazo de 14 días sin dar ningún motivo.
El periodo de desistimiento vencerá a los 14 días desde que usted, o un tercero que no sea el transportista e indicado por usted, adquiera la posesión física del último bien o del último lote o pieza.
Para ejercer el derecho de desistimiento, complete de forma electrónica y envíe una declaración clara en nuestro sitio web, desde "Mis compras" en "Mi cuenta". Le enviaremos sin demora un acuse de recibo de dicho desistimiento a través de un soporte duradero (por ejemplo, por correo electrónico).
Para cumplir con el plazo de desistimiento, basta con que envíe su comunicación relativa al ejercicio del derecho de desistimiento antes de que venza el periodo de desistimiento.
Efectos del desistimiento
Si rescinde este contrato, le reembolsaremos todos los pagos que hayamos recibido de usted, incluidos los gastos de envío (excepto los gastos adicionales que surjan si elige un tipo de envío que no sea el tipo de envío estándar más económico que ofrecemos).
Podemos hacer una deducción del reembolso por la pérdida de valor de cualquier bien suministrado, si la pérdida es el resultado de una manipulación innecesaria por su parte.
Efectuaremos el reembolso sin demoras indebidas y, a más tardar, 14 días después de que se nos informe de su decisión de rescindir este contrato.
Efectuaremos el reembolso utilizando el mismo medio de pago que utilizó para la transacción inicial, a menos que haya acordado expresamente lo contrario; en cualquier caso, no incurrirá en ningún cargo como resultado de dicho reembolso.
Podremos retener el reembolso hasta que hayamos recibido los bienes o hasta que nos haya presentado una prueba de que los ha devuelto, lo que ocurra primero.
Deberá devolver los bienes o entregarlos a Clevedon Community Bookshop Benefit Society, Clevedon, United Kingdom, sin demoras indebidas y, en cualquier caso, en un plazo máximo de 14 días a partir del día en que nos comunique su desistimiento del presente contrato. El plazo se cumple si devuelve la mercancía antes de que venza el periodo de 14 días. Tendrá que asumir los gastos directos de devolución de los bienes. Usted solo es responsable de la disminución del valor de los bienes como resultado de una manipulación distinta a la necesaria para establecer la naturaleza, las características y el funcionamiento de los bienes.
Excepciones al derecho de desistimiento
El derecho de desistimiento no se aplica a lo siguiente:
- La entrega de periódicos, diarios o revistas, con la excepción de los contratos de suscripción; y
- El suministro de contenido digital que no se proporcione en un soporte tangible (por ejemplo, en un CD o DVD) si, al hacer el pedido, aceptó que podíamos empezar a entregarlo y que no podría desistir una vez iniciada la entrega.
Condiciones de envío
We pack our books in corrugated book wrap or book boxes. We try to respond to orders the same day as we receive them or during the next business day. Shipping costs are based on books weighing up to 1.1 lb, or 0.5KG. If your book order is particularly heavy or oversized, we may contact you to request an additional payment to cover extra postage costs.