"Dyer's clever bit of detective work merits as much praise as his deft narrative." -- Daniel E. Sutherland, Journal of Southern History
"A groundbreaking account... An important addition to Civil War scholarship, and an important reminder that history cannot be written in black and white." -- Kirkus Reviews
"Dyer captures the intricacies of multiple loyalties in the midst of seemingly unified secessionist sentiment. Skillfully written and carefully researched, this book is intended for both scholars and a general audience. Highly recommended." -- Library Journal
"As Dyer observes, 'For Atlanta Unionists (and for many Confederates as well), loyalty was frequently imperfect, rarely unconditional, and often influenced by circumstances.' His study has indeed provided new insights into one of the most complex and dramatic aspects of Civil War history." -- Harriet E. Amos Doss, Journal of American History