Madness Unchained: A Reading of Virgil's Aeneid - Tapa dura

At last, a commentary on the Aeneid that doesn't need more decoding devices than Virgil's poem! Dr. Fratantuono's book stands apart for its adherence to a sensible, and yet profound, analysis of a poem that too often in the last several decades hasbeen the testing ground for any number of new approaches to literary criticism. F begins with a heartfelt lament on the way Books VII-XII have been practically ignored in the curricula of American Classical education at all levels. His commentary attemptsto correct this by paying due attention to what V himself considered to be the greater part of his poem. One of my favorite features of F's book is the way the author weaves into his commentary the relevant passages from the poem, and, in so doing, keeps the commentary focused strictly on the passages. The translations, which by F's own admission, do not aspire to any 'literary greatness,' are still some of the best I have ever read. (Perhaps F's description of all translations of the Aeneid as 'betrayals' of the original Latin poem is in fact a tad too harsh.) Like V, who did not compose his opus in a 'linear fashion' but who worked on individual sections as the spirit moved him, F chose to write a commentary which, while remarkably coherent, ca -- Blaise Nagy, College of the Holy Cross Madness Unchained is truly a stunning achievement! Fratantuono's engaging commentary on Virgil's Aeneid, written in lucid and economical prose, has something to offer everyone, from novice readers of the epic to seasoned, veteran scholars. There is much to glean from these pages, whether one dips in to read the author's comments on individual scenes or uses the commentary to accompany a reading of Virgil's epic in its entirety. One of Fratantuono's primary contributions to Virgilian scholarship is the way in which he treats the epic as a whole, illustrating brilliantly that the poem is more than merely a sum of its individual parts. The reader will appreciate Fratantuono's close and perceptive reading of the epic together with his masterful and authoritative survey of existing scholarship. This commentary will prove itself as a worthy sourcebook for generations of Virgil readers to come. -- Mary McHugh, Gustavus Adolphus College a wonderful book, because with its well-versed learning in all aspects of Vergilian scholarship it inspires its readers to think independently. * Bryn Mawr Classical Review, December 2007 * Summing Up: Recommended. Lower-/upper-division undergraduates. * CHOICE, Vol. 45 No. 6 (February 2008) * Fratantuono's detailed, image-by-image and often even line-by-line examination is the most thorough analysis of The Aeneid to appear in decades. It has the great virtue of not shying away from the most difficult cruces in the long interpretative history of the work, and it offers fresh insights into many of them. The readings he offers of individual passages are frequently not only provocative but also suggestive of further possibilities for extended exploration. In short, this is a book that will challenge many of us to rethink our presuppositions about many an aspect of Virgil's epic. -- Robert S. Dupree, The University of Dallas At last, a commentary on the Aeneid that doesn't need more decoding devices than Virgil's poem! Dr. Fratantuono's book stands apart for its adherence to a sensible, and yet profound, analysis of a poem that too often in the last several decades has been the testing ground for any number of new approaches to literary criticism. F begins with a heartfelt lament on the way Books VII-XII have been practically ignored in the curricula of American Classical education at all levels. His commentary attempts to correct this by paying due attention to what V himself considered to be the "greater part" of his poem. One of my favorite features of F's book is the way the author weaves into his commentary the relevant passages from the poem, and, in so doing, keeps the commentary focused strictly on the passages. The translations, which by F's own admission, do not aspire to any 'literary greatness,' are still some of the best I have ever read. (Perhaps F's description of all translations of the Aeneid as 'betrayals' of the original Latin poem is in fact a tad too harsh.) Like V, who did not compose his opus in a 'linear fashion' but who worked on individual sections as the spirit moved him, F chose to write a commentary which, while remarkably coherent, can nevertheless be read with profit in installments and in whatever order the reader selects. One thing is for sure: whatever part of the commentary a person reads, it soon becomes clear that these are the musings of a scholar who, through assiduous study and reflection, has an ear for Virgil and who can, at all times, see a passage within the larger themes of the poem. While not new, F's view, that the Aeneid embodies a 'profound reflection on the nature of the Augustan regime in Rome,' is presented in ways that are fresh and not at all hackneyed. Readers of all ages will profit from F's book. It will doubtless be welcomed by secondary school instructors, who will find in the commentary a perfect complement to their work in the classroom with the La -- Blaise Nagy, College of the Holy Cross

The book aims at providing a coherent guide to the entirety of Virgil's Aeneid, with analysis of every scene and, in some cases, every line of crucial passages. The book tries to provide a guide to the vast bibliography and scholarly apparatus that has grown around Virgil studies (especially over the past century), and to offer some critical study of what Virgil's purpose and intent may have been in crafting his response to Augustus' political ascendancy in Rome, Rome's history of near-constant civil strife, and the myths of Rome's origins and their conflicting Trojan, Greek, and native Italian origins.